11 Risk-Reward Situations: When to Go For It vs Play it Safe

You're standing on the tee of that par-5 16th hole. Water guards the left side. The green is reachable in two—if you thread the needle between those bunkers. Your buddies are watching. Your heart pounds a little faster.

Should you go for it or lay up?

This scenario haunts weekend golfers everywhere. We dream of the hero shot, but fear the disaster that often follows. The difference between breaking 90 and another frustrating round often comes down to these pivotal moments—these risk-reward situations that can make or break your scorecard.

Golfer contemplating risk-reward shot over water hazardThe mental battle between glory and safety plays out on every hole.

Why Risk-Reward Decisions Matter More Than You Think

I've learned the hard way that course management isn't just for the pros. After 25 years as a weekend warrior, I've come to a startling conclusion: the difference between shooting 95 and 85 often has nothing to do with swing mechanics.

It's about making smarter decisions in those critical moments.

The pros understand this. According to Golf Digest's analysis of strokes gained, tour players aren't just better swingers—they're better decision-makers. They take on risks when the odds favor them and play conservatively when they don't.

Here's the kicker: weekend golfers stand to gain even more from smart decision-making because our mistakes are more costly. When a pro misses, they might still save par. When we miss... well, you know how ugly it gets.

🎯 Decision Impact

  • ⭐ Poor decisions account for 4-6 strokes per round for most amateurs
  • 🔍 Risk assessment should consider your ability, not your aspirations
  • 💡 The safest play is often the smartest play for weekend golfers

The 11 Most Common Risk-Reward Situations (And How to Handle Them)

Let's dive into the specific scenarios you'll face and create a game plan for each. I'll share my own experiences and what I've learned from analyzing thousands of weekend rounds.

1. The Reachable Par 5

The Situation: You've hit a decent drive on a par 5, leaving about 220-240 yards to the green. There's trouble around the green (water, bunkers, etc.).

The Risk Play: Go for the green in two, trying to set up an eagle putt or easy birdie.

The Safe Play: Lay up to your comfortable wedge distance (usually 80-110 yards).

When to Go For It: When you're trailing in a match, when the trouble is only on one side (allowing a bailout area), or when you're playing particularly well that day. Also consider going for it if the green is large and receptive.

When to Play Safe: When you're ahead in a match, when you struggle with long approach shots, or when there's trouble surrounding most of the green. Also play safe when the lie isn't perfect or when wind conditions are unfavorable.

I learned this lesson on my home course's 14th hole. For years, I automatically pulled out 3-wood trying to reach in two. My success rate? Maybe 1 in 10 attempts. When I finally started laying up to my favorite wedge distance, my average score on that hole dropped by almost a full stroke.

2. Carrying the Hazard Off the Tee

The Situation: A water hazard, ravine, or waste area that cuts across the fairway at your typical driving distance.

The Risk Play: Hit driver trying to carry the hazard completely.

The Safe Play: Use a shorter club to lay up short of the hazard.

When to Go For It: When the landing area beyond the hazard is wide, when you're hitting your driver well that day, or when the hole plays significantly harder with a longer approach.

When to Play Safe: When you've been struggling with the driver, when the landing area beyond is narrow, or when the extra distance won't significantly help your approach shot.

According to a PGA course management study, amateur golfers who consistently make strategic decisions off the tee rather than automatically grabbing driver score 3-5 strokes better per round.

🎯 Tee Shot Strategy

  • ⚠️ The penalty for missing a forced carry is almost always worse than the benefit of making it
  • 📊 Most amateurs overestimate their carry distance by 15-20 yards
  • ✅ Factor in your typical miss pattern when deciding to challenge hazards

3. Tight Driving Hole with OB/Hazard

The Situation: A narrow driving hole with out of bounds or hazard down one or both sides.

The Risk Play: Hit driver for maximum distance.

The Safe Play: Hit a more accurate club (hybrid, iron) to keep the ball in play.

When to Go For It: When the fairway widens at your typical driver distance, when the hole is very long, or when you need a lower score and are willing to risk a blowup hole.

When to Play Safe: When keeping the ball in play is paramount, when the hole doesn't require maximum distance, or when consistency is more important than distance (like when protecting a lead).

This is where ego usually gets the better of weekend golfers. I remember a round where I stubbornly hit driver on every tight hole, resulting in three penalties. My buddy outscored me by 5 strokes despite being 30 yards behind me on the "successful" drives. Sometimes, position really is more important than power.

4. Recovery From Trouble

The Situation: Your ball is in the trees, rough, or an awkward lie.

The Risk Play: Thread the needle and try to reach the green.

The Safe Play: Punch out to the fairway, accepting the loss of a stroke.

When to Go For It: When there's a clear path to at least part of the green, when the consequences of missing the recovery shot aren't severe, or when you absolutely need a par or better.

When to Play Safe: When the chance of successfully executing the hero shot is low, when making double bogey or worse would be devastating, or when the lie makes controlling the shot difficult.

The USGA rules regarding unplayable lies give you options that many players forget. Sometimes taking an unplayable lie penalty is actually the percentage play compared to attempting a miracle shot.

5. The Tucked Pin Position

The Situation: The pin is placed near the edge of the green, often protected by a hazard.

The Risk Play: Aim directly at the pin, trying to get close for a birdie chance.

The Safe Play: Aim for the center of the green, accepting a longer putt.

When to Go For It: When you're confident with the club in hand, when there's a bailout area, or when you need a birdie.

When to Play Safe: When missing on the wrong side means a likely bogey or worse, when you're not hitting your irons well, or when par is a good score on the hole.

After years of firing at sucker pins, I've adopted a new approach. I now divide the green into "go zones" and "no-go zones" during my pre-round preparation. Pins in no-go zones get center-of-green targets, no matter how tempting they look. This simple strategy has eliminated many three-putts and short-side disasters from my game.

🎯 Pin Position Strategy

  • 🎯 Aim for the fat part of the green when pins are within 5 steps of the edge
  • 🧠 Think about where you can't afford to miss before choosing your target
  • 📊 Two-putting from 30 feet is more likely than getting up-and-down from a difficult spot

6. The Forced Carry Approach

The Situation: Your approach shot requires carrying a hazard (typically water) all the way to the green with no bailout area.

The Risk Play: Go directly at the pin, taking on the full carry.

The Safe Play: Bail out to the side (if possible) or lay up short of the hazard.

When to Go For It: When you're hitting the required club well, when you need to make up strokes, or when the bailout areas are almost as difficult as the carry itself.

When to Play Safe: When you're not confident with the club required, when protecting a good round, or when the penalty for missing is severe.

This situation accounts for more "blow-up holes" than almost any other. Remember that most weekend golfers will score better taking a safe bogey than risking a triple or worse going for a miracle par. As Today's Golfer notes in their mental game section, accepting a bogey on difficult holes is part of good course management.

7. The Long Bunker Shot

The Situation: You're in a greenside bunker with a lot of green to work with.

The Risk Play: Try to splash it close to the hole.

The Safe Play: Focus on just getting out safely, even if it means a longer putt.

When to Go For It: When you're confident in your bunker play, when the sand conditions are good, or when you need to get close to save par.

When to Play Safe: When you struggle with bunker shots, when the sand is unfamiliar, or when a big number would be disastrous.

I've learned that in bunkers, most weekend golfers (myself included) should focus on just getting out first. The difference between a 25-foot putt and a 10-foot putt isn't worth the risk of leaving it in the sand. Once you start consistently getting out in one shot, then you can work on getting closer.

8. The Fairway vs. Distance Decision

The Situation: A dogleg hole where cutting the corner offers more distance but higher risk.

The Risk Play: Cut the corner, aiming over the rough or hazard.

The Safe Play: Follow the fairway around the dogleg, accepting a longer approach.

When to Go For It: When the reward significantly shortens the hole, when your reliable shot shape matches the hole design, or when there's a reasonable bailout area.

When to Play Safe: When the penalty for missing is severe, when the advantage gained is minimal, or when your typical miss would be problematic.

Many of our golf strategy articles emphasize that position off the tee is far more important than an extra 20-30 yards for most amateurs. The statistics don't lie—approach shots from the fairway are significantly more accurate than from the rough, regardless of the club in your hand.

9. The Trouble-Filled Par 3

The Situation: A par 3 with hazards around the green (water, deep bunkers, etc.).

The Risk Play: Aim directly at the pin.

The Safe Play: Aim for the safest part of the green or even the fringe if the green is small and heavily guarded.

When to Go For It: When the pin is in a relatively accessible position, when you're hitting your irons well, or when you need a birdie.

When to Play Safe: When the pin is in a difficult position, when the consequences of missing are severe, or when bogey or worse would hurt your round significantly.

On one particularly challenging par 3 at my local course, I've learned that aiming for the middle of the green—regardless of pin position—leads to significantly better scores over time. The hole yields very few birdies anyway, and avoiding big numbers has been much more valuable to my overall score.

🎯 Par 3 Strategy

  • 🧠 Commit to your target completely—indecision leads to poor execution
  • ⛳ Club selection is more important than precision on difficult par 3s
  • 📊 Most amateurs should play to the fat part of the green on 80% of par 3s

10. The Long Putt Strategy

The Situation: You're facing a very long putt (40+ feet) with significant break.

The Risk Play: Try to make it, accepting the risk of a three-putt.

The Safe Play: Focus purely on distance control to ensure a two-putt.

When to Go For It: When you need a birdie, when the green is relatively predictable, or during a friendly round when there's not much pressure.

When to Play Safe: When avoiding three-putts is critical, when the green is very fast or has multiple breaks, or when your touch on longer putts has been off that day.

I've found that breaking long putts into segments helps tremendously. I don't try to make anything over 30 feet—instead, I visualize a 3-foot circle around the hole and try to get the ball within that circle. This approach has dramatically reduced my three-putts while still occasionally yielding surprise one-putts.

11. The Final Hole Decision

The Situation: You're playing the last hole with your score in mind (trying to break 80, 90, or 100).

The Risk Play: Play aggressively to try to make the score you want.

The Safe Play: Focus on avoiding disaster to protect the score you have.

When to Go For It: When you need a birdie or par to reach your goal and bogey or worse doesn't matter.

When to Play Safe: When a conservative bogey will still let you reach your goal, or when protecting against a blowup hole is the priority.

This is the ultimate mental challenge. I've blown too many good rounds on the 18th hole by thinking about my score instead of the shot at hand. Now I have a simple rule: play the 18th hole exactly as I would play it on any other day, with the same strategy and club selections. The consistency of this approach has saved me from many last-hole disasters.

My Weekend Warrior Risk Assessment Framework

After years of trial and error, I've developed a simple framework any weekend golfer can use to make better risk-reward decisions:

  1. Honestly assess your skill level for the required shot - Not your best-ever version, but your typical skill level

  2. Estimate your success percentage - Be brutally honest: "Out of 10 attempts, how many would be successful?"

  3. Consider the consequences of failure - How bad is the worst-case scenario?

  4. Apply the 70% rule - If you can't execute the shot successfully at least 7 out of 10 times in normal conditions, take the safer option

This simple approach has saved me countless strokes. When I'm being honest with myself, there are very few hero shots I can pull off at a 70% success rate. This realization alone has lowered my typical scores by 3-5 strokes.

🎯 Decision Framework

  • ⭐ Always consider your average skill, not your peak performance
  • ⚠️ The higher your handicap, the more you benefit from conservative play
  • 🧠 Make decisions before you reach your ball to avoid emotional choices

How Betting Impacts Risk-Reward Decisions

Let's be real—many weekend golfers play with a few dollars on the line. This changes the equation considerably.

In stroke play with money at stake, safe plays become even more valuable. The risk of a blow-up hole can cost you the match instantly.

In match play, however, the calculus changes. If you're down in a match, taking calculated risks makes sense because losing by one hole or three holes is the same outcome. This is one of the few situations where aggressive play can be the percentage decision, even for weekend golfers.

When playing for skins or closest to the pin, isolated risks can make mathematical sense when the potential reward (winning multiple skins, for example) outweighs the cost of a single bad hole.

The Mental Game of Risk-Reward Decisions

Making good decisions is only half the battle. The real challenge is sticking to them when emotions take over. Here are some mental techniques I've learned:

  1. Pre-round planning - Identify the 3-4 key decision points on the course before you play

  2. Commit completely - Once you've made a decision, commit to it 100%

  3. Focus on the process, not the outcome - A good decision can still lead to a bad result due to random factors

  4. Have a short memory - Don't let one bad outcome change your strategy for the rest of the round

  5. Post-round review - Analyze your decisions after the round when emotions aren't running high

The mental battle between your ego ("I can make this shot!") and your rational brain ("The percentages say to lay up") is the true test of golf wisdom. Learning to quiet your ego will lead to better scores more consistently.

Key Takeaways

When deciding between risk and safety on the golf course, remember these crucial points:

  • Most weekend golfers should choose the safer play in at least 80% of risk-reward situations
  • Use the 70% rule—if you can't execute the shot successfully 7 out of 10 times, take the safer option
  • Pre-plan your strategy for each hole before your round begins
  • Your typical skill level (not your best-ever shots) should determine your strategy
  • The higher your handicap, the more you benefit from conservative play
  • Develop a simple risk assessment framework you can use under pressure
  • Don't let one hole's outcome (good or bad) change your strategy for the next hole
  • Review your decisions after the round to learn from both successes and failures

Smart Golf Decisions: Risk vs. Reward Questions Answered

Should weekend golfers take more or fewer risks than pros?
Weekend golfers should generally take fewer risks than pros. Professional golfers have the skill to recover from trouble spots that would lead to big numbers for amateurs. Additionally, pros practice specific high-risk shots extensively, while amateurs rarely practice recovery shots. The general rule: the higher your handicap, the more conservative your strategy should be.

How do I know if I should go for the green in two on a par 5?
Apply the 70% rule: If you can hit the required shot successfully at least 7 out of 10 times, consider going for it. Other factors to consider: 1) Is there a bailout area if you miss? 2) How comfortable are you with the club required? 3) Are the green conditions receptive? 4) What's the state of your game that day? For most weekend golfers, laying up to a comfortable wedge distance (80-110 yards) will yield better scores over time.

Should I aim at pins that are tucked near hazards?
For most weekend golfers, aiming at tucked pins is a low-percentage play. Instead, divide the green into 'go' and 'no-go' zones during your pre-round preparation. Pins within 5 steps of the edge, especially when guarded by hazards, should generally be avoided in favor of the center of the green. Remember that a 30-foot putt for birdie is better than a short-sided chip or bunker shot when you miss the aggressive play.

How should my risk tolerance change during a round of golf?
Your risk tolerance should adjust based on: 1) How you're playing that day—if you're striking the ball well, you can be slightly more aggressive, 2) Your score—if you're having a great round, protecting that score becomes more important, 3) The specific hole—some holes naturally demand conservative play, 4) Match situation—if you're trailing in match play, calculated risks make more sense. The key is making these adjustments consciously rather than emotionally.

What's the biggest risk-reward mistake weekend golfers make?
The biggest mistake is overestimating their ability to execute difficult shots. Most amateurs remember their rare successes but forget their frequent failures. This leads to overly aggressive play that results in blow-up holes. The second biggest mistake is making emotional decisions under pressure rather than sticking to a pre-determined strategy. Developing a simple decision framework before the pressure situations arise can help avoid these costly errors.

How should I approach risk-reward decisions when playing a new course?
When playing an unfamiliar course, err on the side of caution. Unknown factors like green firmness, rough thickness, and hazard severity make risk assessment more difficult. Study the scorecard and any available course guides before playing. During the round, look for obvious bailout areas and favor the high-percentage play. Many golfers find that their second round on a course is significantly better than their first because they make more informed strategic decisions.

Should my typical ball flight pattern affect my risk-reward decisions?
Absolutely! Your typical miss pattern should heavily influence your strategy. If you tend to slice the ball, pins tucked on the right side of greens become even riskier targets. Similarly, if you typically pull your drives, doglegs to the right might require more conservative play. Smart course management involves playing to your tendencies rather than fighting them. Design your strategy around the shots you're most likely to hit, not the ideal shots you hope to hit.

Show / Hide

More Risk and Reward Golf Resources