- Home
- Weekend Golfer Life
- Why We Keep Playing
- Holding Up Your Foursome
The Bunker Isn't the Problem. Holding Up Your Foursome Is.
Three swings in and the ball still hasn't cleared the lip. Behind you, someone in your group has already picked up their bag and started drifting toward the green — not out of rudeness, just because there's genuinely nothing left for them to do but stand there and wait. That's the actual bunker problem. It was never really about the sand.
Here's the direct answer, because you need it before anything else: in a casual round, give yourself two honest swings at getting out, three at the absolute outside, then pick up, drop clear of the bunker, and take the stroke. Nobody in your Saturday foursome is tracking your actual score in the sand — they're tracking how long you're standing in it, and the USGA's own pace-of-play guidance backs the pick-up-and-move-on approach for anything outside individual stroke play.
Golfeaser isn't going to tell you to open the clubface, hit two inches behind the ball, and follow through high. You've heard some version of that a hundred times, from a hundred slow-motion YouTube swings, and it hasn't stuck — because the swing was never really what was keeping you stuck in the sand. What keeps you stuck is the audience. Four guys who've seen you do this before, on a Saturday morning that's supposed to be fun, watching you try to solve a problem you only face a handful of times a season. That's not a technique gap. That's a nerve problem wearing a technique costume, and it's exactly the kind of thing I try to improve my own experience around instead of pretending I've fixed it for good.
Why Bunkers Feel Worse Than They Actually Are
A topped drive into the rough doesn't have a crowd. Nobody's standing at the edge of the fairway with their arms crossed, watching you hunt for your ball in the trees. But a bunker puts you in a small, visible hole in the ground, in full view of everyone in your group, for exactly as long as it takes you to get out. That's not a harder shot. That's a more watched one, and your brain treats those very differently.
The first time I truly lost it in a bunker was on the 14th at a course outside Charlotte — three swings, three failures, and the group behind us watching the whole thing over their steering wheels while they waited on the tee. Mike still brings it up every time I get a little too confident standing over a tee shot.
It's the same physics as first-tee nerves — the shot itself isn't harder than a hundred others you've hit that day, the stakes just feel higher because someone's watching and waiting on you. And the thing first-tee nerves eventually teach you applies here too: confidence has nothing to do with your handicap. It has to do with how fast you can let a bad shot just be a bad shot and keep the group moving.
How Many Swings Before You Just Pick It Up?
This is the real etiquette question, and for the vast majority of rounds you'll ever play, it's a social question, not a rules question. Nobody's turning in a card. Nobody's protecting a handicap index down to the decimal. The thing actually at stake is your group's pace and mood, and both of those start to sour around swing number four.
The informal rule that works for most Saturday groups: two honest attempts, three if the lie is genuinely brutal, then you pick up. Drop the ball clear of the bunker on your way to the green, count the stroke (or don't, if your group plays it looser than that), and keep moving. This isn't quitting. It's recognizing that the point of the round is the round, not the sand save.
Here's the honest breakdown of when to keep swinging and when to just take the drop and go:
Whichever branch you land on, the pattern underneath it is the same: decide your number before you're standing in the sand, not while you're standing in it. Deciding in the moment is how three swings quietly becomes six.
What the Rulebook Actually Says (For the One Time It Matters)
If you're ever in a real competition — a club event, a tournament round, anything where a card gets turned in — the informal pick-up rule above doesn't apply, and it's worth knowing what actually does. The official unplayable-ball rule gives you a formal way out: for one penalty stroke, you can go back to your previous spot, drop back along the line the ball came in on and stay in the bunker, or drop within two club-lengths and stay in the bunker. For two penalty strokes instead of one, you can also drop back on that same line outside the bunker entirely — a genuinely useful option when the ball's plugged under a lip and there's no realistic play from where it sits.
That's the one scenario where this stops being a social decision and becomes a rules one. Every other Saturday of your life, it's the informal version that actually governs how the day goes.
Does Picking Up Mess With Your Score or Handicap?
This is the objection a stickler buddy will actually raise, and it deserves a straight answer instead of a shrug. If you're playing a round you plan to post for handicap purposes, the World Handicap System doesn't require you to finish every hole exactly as it lies — it gives you a maximum score per hole (net double bogey) built for exactly this situation. Picking up in a bunker and recording your capped score isn't a workaround. It's how the system is designed to work.
The actual problem isn't picking up. It's doing that math for the first time while three guys wait on the tee. Decide before the round, not during it: are you posting today, or is this just the Saturday game? If you're posting, know your max score for the hole walking in, so a bad bunker lie turns into "that's my max, moving on" instead of a debate held in front of your group. If you're not posting — which, if you're being honest, describes most weekend rounds — none of this applies at all, and the two-or-three-swing rule from earlier is the only math you need.
Where this actually shows up most isn't handicap posting anyway — it's betting formats. Say you're three down in a $5 Nassau and your ball's plugged under the lip on 11. Picking up there usually just means conceding the hole, which your group has almost certainly already worked out informally without anyone opening a rulebook. It's worth knowing roughly what a real 20-handicap's stats actually look like before assuming one blown-up bunker hole is dragging your whole round down more than it actually is — a single bad hole barely moves the needle over eighteen.
Raking, Timing, and Not Being "That Guy"
Getting out of the bunker is only half the etiquette. What you leave behind matters just as much to the group playing behind you, and it takes about eight seconds to do right. Rake on your way out, not before — smoothing the sand while your ball is still sitting in it just means you rake twice. Enter and exit from the low side of the bunker, the side closest to where you're headed next, so you're not tracking footprints across the whole thing on your way to a green you could've reached in three steps.
If you're genuinely holding the group up, rake fast, set your bag down outside the bunker (never inside it — that's its own small etiquette violation), and get moving. Nobody's auditing your rake job. They're auditing how long it takes you to finish it. Forgetting to rake entirely is its own conversation — and its own kind of Saturday-morning story — but taking the extra ten seconds almost always costs less than the awkward walk back to fix it once someone notices.
This is really just ready golf applied to one specific spot on the course. I played it religiously for ten straight rounds a while back, and the bunkers were where it mattered most — not because the shots got any easier, but because I stopped treating the walk in and the walk out as a separate, leisurely event from the shot itself.
⛳ Bunker Etiquette Quick Rules
- ✅ Rake on your way out, not before — smoothing footprints toward the low side as you leave
- 🚫 Don't set your bag or clubs down inside the bunker — rake first, step out, then set down
- ⭐ Enter and exit from the low side closest to your next shot — it's faster and it's the norm
- 💡 If you're holding up the group, rake fast and keep moving — nobody's counting your penalty strokes on a Saturday
What Your Group Actually Thinks (Probably Not What You Think)
Here's the part that surprises most guys once they actually ask: your group isn't grading the swing. Waiting on someone in a bunker is kinda like waiting on a slow elevator — nobody's mad at the person personally, they're just doing quiet math about how long until the doors open. The frustration, when it exists at all, is almost always about pace, not skill.
That's a genuinely different problem to solve than "get better at bunkers," and it's a much easier one. You don't need a better sand shot. You need a faster decision. Some of golf's most universal embarrassing moments live in exactly this gap between what we assume people are thinking and what they're actually thinking, and bunkers are one of the worst offenders. If you've ever felt like the worst golfer in the group over a sand shot specifically, you're grading yourself on a scale nobody else in the foursome is using.
When You're the One Waiting
Etiquette runs both directions, and the waiting side has its own version of the same problem. Standing at the edge of a bunker staring at your buddy mid-swing doesn't speed anything up — it just adds an audience to a moment that already has one too many people watching it.
The better move: turn away, or at least stop watching directly. Get your own club ready for the next shot, check the pin position, do anything other than stand there like a scoreboard. It sounds small, but a group that's visibly not staring makes a bunker shot feel like less of an event, which — full circle — is most of what actually helps someone get out of it faster.
If it's genuinely dragging past that third swing, a simple "take the drop, we're good" from anyone in the group does more than silence ever will. It's permission, not pressure, and it's usually a relief to hear out loud rather than something the guy in the bunker has to decide on his own with three people watching. This is a small piece of what it actually means to make your foursome better — not the shots you hit, but the pressure you take off the guy who's having a rough one.
Building Bunker Confidence Without Turning It Into a Lesson
This isn't about becoming good in the sand — plenty of low-handicap players still hate bunkers, and plenty of 20-handicappers get out fine without ever thinking about it twice. It's about removing the moment where you stand over the ball, run three different thoughts through your head, and turn a five-second shot into a thirty-second production the whole group can feel.
Decide your number of swings before you're in the bunker, not after your first one fails. Treat the bogey as the plan, not the failure — if you're a 20-handicapper, a bogey out of the sand is a perfectly normal hole, not a collapse. And remember that the guy who moves quickly, wins or loses the hole, is the guy who actually makes his foursome better to play with — not the guy who somehow scrambled a par out of it after five extra minutes. That's not a small thing. It's most of what realistic expectations for your game actually come down to: knowing which parts of the round are worth fighting for and which ones are worth just moving past.
The Round Where It Actually Clicked
For a long time I'd stand over a bunker shot re-running two or three different swing thoughts before I ever moved the club. Then one Saturday, standing in a fairway bunker on a hole I'd already decided to write off, I just told myself: two swings, whatever happens happens, and stopped thinking the second the second thought arrived. I haven't hit a genuinely great bunker shot since that day — but I've never held up a group over one either, and it turns out that trade was the one actually worth making.
You're always just one round away from the version of this that doesn't rattle you anymore. It's not a swing you're waiting to find. It's a decision you're waiting to make before you're standing in the sand instead of while you're standing in it — and once you make it once, it's a lot easier to make it again, which is really the whole story behind why we keep coming back to this frustrating game in the first place.
⛳ What Changes Once You Stop Overthinking the Sand
- ⭐ Give yourself two honest swings, three at the most, in any casual round — then pick up and move on
- ✅ Rake from the low side on your way out, every time, without being asked
- 💡 Your group isn't grading your bunker play — they're just waiting on you, so speed matters more than style
- 🎯 Decide your number before you're standing in the sand, not while you're standing in it
- 🏌️ In real competition, the actual rulebook gives you a formal unplayable-ball option — everywhere else, the informal rule is the real etiquette
This is part of the weekend golfer life nobody puts in the instructional videos — the part where the win isn't the shot, it's how little of a moment you make out of it.
🏌️ Got a Golf Story?
Share it with us. Every story we publish earns the author a free copy of The Weekend Golfer's Social Playbook — our three-step system for finding your people, running trips that actually come together, and earning the right to brag at the 19th hole.
Or join the Golfeasers — free weekly content for people like us.
More for Golfers Who'd Rather Not Hold Up the Group
- Why Is Golf So Hard? A 25-Handicapper's Honest Answer
- Playing Smart When You're Not Playing Well
- Are Golf Friends Real Friends?
Frequently Asked Questions
How many swings should I take in a bunker before I just pick up? In a casual round, two honest attempts is the norm, three if the lie is genuinely bad. After that, pick up, drop clear of the bunker, and take the stroke. It keeps pace reasonable and stops one bad lie from turning into a five-minute delay for everyone behind you.
Is it bad etiquette to pick up a ball in a bunker during a casual round? No — outside individual stroke-play competition, picking up your ball to maintain pace is specifically fine, and it's a standard part of how most weekend groups actually play. It only becomes a genuine rules issue in a competition where scores are being recorded.
Why do I get so nervous over bunker shots specifically? It's usually not the shot itself — it's the visibility. A bunker puts you in a small, exposed spot in full view of your group for as long as it takes to finish, which raises the perceived stakes even though the shot isn't objectively harder than plenty of others you hit that round.
Do you rake a bunker before or after you leave it? After. Play your shot, then smooth the sand on your way out, working toward the low side you're exiting from. Raking before you've finished just means doing it twice.
What happens if I'm in a real competition and can't get out of a bunker? The official unplayable-ball rule applies. For one penalty stroke you can go back to your previous spot or drop back in the bunker along the original line or within two club-lengths. For two penalty strokes, you can also drop back along that line outside the bunker entirely — useful when the lie is genuinely unplayable.
Johnny is a 25-year weekend golfer who's double-booked tee times, forgotten his clubs an hour from the course, and made pretty much every other trip-planning mistake there is — so you don't have to. Guided by The Golfeaser Manifesto, he started Golfeaser.com to prove that weekend golfers are a special, funnier breed who improve the experience, not just the scorecard. He's also the guy behind The Weekend Golfer's Social Playbook — a three-step system for finding your people, running trips that actually come together, and earning the right to brag at the 19th hole.
