13 Situations Where Most Golfers Choose the Wrong Club

Ever feel that sinking feeling when you've just watched your perfectly struck shot sail directly into a bunker? Or that frustration when you've hit what felt like a solid swing only to come up embarrassingly short of the green? Brother, I feel your pain.

The ugly truth is that most weekend golfers like us aren't losing strokes because our swing is terrible—we're bleeding shots because we keep choosing the wrong club at crucial moments. I should know—I've made all these mistakes more times than I care to admit.

After years of watching my golf buddies (and myself) make the same club selection blunders over and over, I've identified the 13 most common situations where amateur golfers choose the wrong club. Fix these mistakes, and I guarantee you'll start seeing lower scores without changing your swing one bit.

Frustrated golfer after choosing the wrong clubThat painful moment when you realize you picked the wrong club—we've all been there!

1. The "Always Driver" Syndrome on Par 4s

We've all played with that guy (maybe we are that guy) who pulls out the driver on every par 4 without a second thought. But here's the dirty little secret: sometimes the driver is the absolute worst club you could choose.

On short or heavily hazarded par 4s, pulling driver often means you're bringing more trouble into play. I remember playing with my buddy Rick who insisted on hitting driver on a tight 320-yard par 4. He could hit it about 260 yards, but the fairway narrowed to practically nothing at the 230-yard mark with deep bunkers on both sides.

"Why not hit a 5-iron or hybrid to the widest part of the fairway and leave yourself a comfortable short iron in?" I suggested.

"Because I didn't buy this $500 driver to leave it in the bag," he replied.

Three tee shots and three bunker visits later, Rick finally understood why the driver wasn't always the right call.

The smart play: Analyze the hole layout. If hazards come into play at your normal driver distance or the fairway significantly narrows, reach for a 3-wood, hybrid, or even a long iron that will keep you short of trouble. As Practical Golf points out, knowing key yardages to hazards before you play can dramatically improve your decision-making.

🎯 Driver Decision Guide

  • ⚠️ If fairway narrows at your driver distance, choose a shorter club
  • 🔍 Look for fairway bunkers in the 220-270 yard range—they're specifically placed to catch drives
  • ✅ On wide-open holes with no trouble, grip it and rip it!

2. Using Distance-Only for Approach Shots

Picture this: you're 150 yards from the pin, so naturally, you grab your trusty 150-yard club. Simple, right? Wrong! This is one of the deadliest club selection mistakes I see weekend golfers make.

Here's why this is a problem: that 150-yard distance is only part of the equation. Is the pin tucked behind a bunker? Is it on the front of the green with trouble short? Is there a slope that will funnel your ball away from the target?

I'll never forget watching my friend Joe aim directly at a front pin with water short. Of course, he took his exact 160-yard club for a 160-yard shot. What happened? His slightly thin shot—which we all hit occasionally—skipped right into the water. Had he aimed for the center of the green with one more club, he'd have been putting for birdie instead of dropping for his fourth shot.

The smart play: When approaching greens, aim for the center or even the back of the green rather than fixating on the pin, especially when the pin is in a dangerous position. Take one more club than you think you need and swing smoothly—you'll hit more greens and avoid those killer short-side misses.

3. The Wrong Club from Fairway Bunkers

Fairway bunkers strike fear in the hearts of weekend golfers everywhere—and for good reason. But much of that fear stems from poor club selection.

The classic mistake? Trying to hit the same club you would from the fairway. When you're in a fairway bunker, you need to account for a few things:

  • You can't take your normal divot
  • You need to hit the ball cleaner
  • Maintaining balance is harder in sand

I recently played with my buddy Mark who found himself in a fairway bunker about 170 yards out. He pulled his 5-iron—the club he'd normally hit from that distance. His club dug into the sand behind the ball, the shot traveled maybe 100 yards, and he ended up with a double bogey.

The smart play: Take at least one more club than normal (sometimes two), choke down slightly, play the ball a bit farther back in your stance, and focus on making clean contact rather than distance. The goal from a fairway bunker is to get back in play, not to hit a hero shot.

🎯 Fairway Bunker Club Selection

  • ⭐ Take 1-2 more clubs than you normally would
  • 🔍 Check the lip height—it dictates how much loft you need
  • ❌ Avoid using hybrids—they tend to dig into the sand

4. The "Too Much Club" Downhill Lie

Downhill lies are tricky beasts that routinely fool weekend golfers into making the wrong club selection. The most common mistake? Not accounting for how much a downhill lie will reduce your distance and lower your ball flight.

I played with my neighbor Dave last summer, and he faced a downhill lie with about 160 yards to the green. He grabbed his usual 160-yard club (a 7-iron for him), made what looked like a good swing, and watched in dismay as his ball fell 20 yards short of the green. The downhill lie had robbed him of distance and trajectory.

The smart play: When facing a downhill lie, take at least one less club (sometimes two for steeper slopes). The ball will naturally launch lower and won't travel as far. Also, expect the ball to fade (move right for right-handed golfers) more than usual, so aim accordingly.

5. The Uphill "Not Enough Club" Error

The opposite of the downhill lie problem, but just as common, is not taking enough club from an uphill lie. When the ball is above your feet, it dramatically changes how far the ball will travel.

An uphill lie has several effects:

  • The ball launches higher
  • You lose distance
  • The ball tends to draw (move left for right-handed golfers)

Yet I constantly see players fail to account for this. My golf buddy Paul regularly takes his normal club from uphill lies, hits what feels like a great shot, and then watches in frustration as his ball balloons into the air and lands well short of the target.

The smart play: Take at least one more club (sometimes two for steeper hills) from an uphill lie. Also, aim a bit right (for right-handed players) to allow for the natural draw. The steeper the slope, the more club you need.

6. The "Wrong Wedge" Around the Green

I've watched countless amateurs grab their most lofted wedge for virtually every shot around the green, regardless of the situation. This is like trying to fix every home repair with a hammer—sometimes you need a screwdriver!

The perfect example was my buddy Tim, who found himself just off the green with 30 feet of run to the hole on a firm surface. He automatically grabbed his 60-degree wedge, hit a lovely high shot that landed softly—and then watched it roll 15 feet past the hole because the green was like concrete that day.

The smart play: Assess the shot before grabbing a club. Consider:

  • How much green do you have to work with?
  • Is the green running fast or slow?
  • Are there any obstacles to carry?

Often, a 9-iron bump-and-run or even a hybrid or putter from off the green will give you better distance control than a high-lofted wedge. As GOLF Top 100 Teacher Kellie Stenzel suggests, having multiple short game options and choosing based on what's working that day will save you strokes.

🎯 Around the Green Club Options

  • 🧠 For maximum roll and minimum air time: 7-9 iron or hybrid
  • ⛳ For some height but still good roll: Pitching or gap wedge
  • 📊 For maximum height and minimum roll: Sand or lob wedge

7. The "Too Much Club" Into the Wind

We've all done it—the pin is 150 yards away, but there's a stiff headwind. So what do we do? Take our 140-yard club and swing harder to get there. The result? A thin, low shot that gets hammered by the wind or a wild miss because we overswung.

One memorable round, my golf buddy Frank kept coming up short on a windy day. "Hit more club and swing easier," I suggested. He ignored me for the front nine, then tried it on the back. The difference was dramatic—he hit eight greens on the back nine after hitting only two on the front.

The smart play: Into a headwind, take at least one to two more clubs than normal and make a smooth, controlled swing. Trying to "beat" the wind with a harder swing usually backfires. Keep the ball flight lower by positioning it slightly back in your stance and choking down a bit.

8. The "Too Little Club" Shooting Downwind

Just as common as taking too little club into the wind is taking too much club downwind. When playing with a tailwind, many golfers overestimate how much the wind will help.

I've seen my regular playing partner Jeff repeatedly air-mail greens downwind because he takes two clubs less, expecting the wind to dramatically increase his distance. But unless it's blowing 25+ mph, the effect is usually less than expected.

The smart play: With a tailwind, take only one less club at most, and still make your normal swing. Remember that a tailwind also reduces spin, so the ball will likely run more when it lands. Account for this extra roll when picking your landing spot.

9. The "Hero Club" from the Rough

We've all been there—you've driven it into the rough, and you're still 180 yards from the green. The natural instinct is to grab the same club you'd hit from the fairway at that distance. But the rough has other ideas.

The rough affects your shot in several key ways:

  • It reduces your distance significantly
  • It reduces your ability to control the clubface
  • It makes it harder to get the ball airborne

Yet I constantly see weekend golfers try to muscle a long iron or hybrid through thick rough, only to watch the ball travel 30-50 yards less than expected or shoot off in a random direction.

The smart play: From thick rough, take at least one or two more clubs than normal, accept that you'll lose distance, and focus on getting back in play rather than trying to reach the green from 180+ yards. Sometimes, a simple pitch-out to the fairway is the smartest play of all.

🎯 Rough Recovery Guide

  • ⚠️ Light rough: Take one more club than normal
  • ⭐ Medium rough: Take two more clubs and accept distance loss
  • ❌ Heavy rough: Forget distance—focus on getting back to the fairway

10. The Wrong Club Off the Tee on a Tight Par 5

Par 5s present a unique club selection challenge. The typical weekend golfer mindset is "I need to hit driver to have any chance of reaching in two," but this often leads to trouble.

Last month, I played with a group of buddies at a course with a narrow par 5 that had out-of-bounds down the entire right side. Three of them hit driver, and two found the OB. The third guy hit a great drive but was still left with 260+ yards over water—a shot he had almost no chance of pulling off.

The smart play: On tight par 5s, consider a 3-wood or even a long iron off the tee. Keeping the ball in play is far more important than extra distance if that distance leaves you with an impossible second shot or, worse, puts you in trouble. A more conservative tee shot that sets up a comfortable layup and wedge approach often leads to better scores than the "bomb and gouge" approach.

11. The "Always Lob Wedge" Bunker Mistake

Sand shots require careful club selection, but most weekend golfers automatically reach for their most lofted wedge regardless of the situation. This is often a mistake.

I watched my friend Dan try to hit a 60-degree wedge out of a bunker with a very high lip. The ball slammed into the face and fell back into the sand. After two more failed attempts, he finally took my advice and used his 56-degree sand wedge with a more open face. The ball popped out easily.

The smart play: Match your wedge to the bunker situation. For standard bunkers, a sand wedge (54-56 degrees) is usually best. For bunkers with very high lips, you might need your lob wedge. For shallow bunkers with lots of green to work with, a gap wedge might be the better choice. The key is to assess each bunker shot independently rather than defaulting to the same club every time.

12. The "Not Enough Club" to Carry Water

Water hazards create psychological challenges that lead to poor club selection. The most common mistake? Taking just enough club to carry the water if you hit it perfectly.

My buddy Steve is notorious for this. He'll laser a shot at 155 yards over water and pull his 155-yard club. Then he'll get nervous about the water, tense up, make a poor swing, and splash. Even after years of this happening, he still hasn't learned to take more club.

The smart play: When faced with a forced carry over water, take at least one more club than you think you need. The extra club serves two purposes: it provides a margin for error in case you don't catch it perfectly, and it often helps you swing more relaxed knowing you have plenty of club to clear the hazard.

🎯 Water Hazard Strategy

  • ⭐ Take one more club than the exact carry distance
  • 🧠 Focus on a target well beyond the water, not the hazard itself
  • ✅ Make a smooth swing—trying to "help" the ball over usually backfires

13. The Wrong Putter for the Situation

Yes, even putting involves club selection decisions! Many golfers use their standard putter for every situation on the green, ignoring how the fringe or collar might affect the roll.

I remember watching my regular foursome all struggle with putts that had to travel through 2-3 feet of fringe before reaching the green. Each of them used their putter, and each came up woefully short as the fringe grabbed their ball.

The smart play: When faced with a putt that must travel through significant fringe, consider using a hybrid or 7-iron instead of your putter. These clubs pop the ball into a gentle roll that handles the fringe much better than a traditional putter. Conversely, for fast downhill putts, sometimes using the toe of your putter can deaden the hit and give you better distance control.

Keys to Better Club Selection

Now that we've covered the 13 most common club selection mistakes, let's talk about how to make better decisions going forward:

  1. Know your actual distances, not your "one-time-I-hit-it-this-far" distances. Keep track of how far you truly hit each club on average.

  2. Factor in conditions before choosing a club—wind, elevation, temperature, and lie all affect distance.

  3. Play to the fat part of greens rather than chasing pins. As Golf Insider UK notes, great players frequently aim away from flags and toward the center of greens.

  4. When in doubt, take more club, not less. It's almost always better to be a little long than a little short.

  5. Develop a pre-shot routine that includes careful club selection. Don't just grab a club out of habit.

I've personally dropped 5 strokes off my handicap simply by improving my club selection without changing my swing. The best part? It didn't require hours on the range or expensive lessons—just better decision-making.

🎯 Club Selection Checklist

  • 🔍 Assess distance, wind, elevation, and lie
  • ⛳ Identify trouble spots to avoid
  • 🧠 Choose the club that gives you the highest probability of success, not the one that works "if you hit it perfectly"

Remember, golf isn't just about how well you swing—it's about how well you think. And smart club selection is one of the easiest ways to lower your scores without changing your swing. Give these tips a try in your next round, and I bet you'll see immediate improvement.

Common Club Selection Questions

Why shouldn't I always hit driver on par 4s?
Driver isn't always the best choice because many par 4s are designed with hazards specifically placed at driver distance for average golfers (220-260 yards). On holes with narrow landing areas or strategic hazards, a 3-wood, hybrid, or long iron can keep you in play and actually result in a better score than risking trouble with driver.

How do I choose the right club for approach shots?
Don't just consider distance to the pin. Factor in wind conditions, elevation changes, pin position, and the best miss location. Often, aiming for the center or even back of the green with one more club than you think you need will produce better results than aiming directly at a tucked pin with the exact-distance club.

What's the biggest club selection mistake weekend golfers make?
The biggest mistake is choosing clubs based solely on distance without considering other factors like wind, lie, elevation, and the position of hazards. Most amateurs also tend to overestimate their distances and choose too little club, leaving them short of their target—statistically the worst place to miss on most holes.

Should I always use my lob wedge around the greens?
No. Club selection around the greens should be based on the shot requirements. For shots requiring maximum roll and minimum flight, a 7-9 iron or hybrid bump-and-run might be better. For standard chips, a pitching or gap wedge often provides better distance control. Only use your lob wedge when you need maximum height and minimum roll.

How do I adjust my club selection in windy conditions?
Into a headwind, take 1-2 more clubs than normal and make a smooth swing rather than trying to hit it harder. With a tailwind, take one less club at most as the effect is often less dramatic than expected. For crosswinds, consider the shot shape—a shot that curves into the wind (a draw into a right-to-left wind for right-handed players) will tend to hold its line better.

Show / Hide

Strategic Club Selection Articles