15 Signs You're Coming Over the Top (And How to Fix It)

That slice is driving you crazy, isn't it? You step up to the tee, take a confident swing, and watch your ball sail off into the trees on the right. Again. The problem might be that you're coming over the top in your golf swing—one of the most common swing faults that plague weekend golfers everywhere.

I've been there myself, standing on the tee box wondering why my perfectly good-looking swing keeps producing these banana balls. After years of weekend rounds and countless range sessions, I've learned to spot the warning signs of an over-the-top swing before it ruins my entire round.

What Exactly Is "Coming Over the Top"?

Coming over the top happens when your golf club approaches the ball from outside the target line during your downswing. Instead of the club dropping into the "slot" and approaching from inside the target line, it gets thrown over the proper swing plane. This creates an out-to-in swing path that typically results in slices, pulls, or that dreaded pull-slice combo.

Think of it like throwing a baseball. If you throw it properly, your arm comes from the inside and releases toward your target. But if you throw it "over the top," your arm comes from outside and across your body—you'd never throw a strike that way. Your golf swing works similarly.

The frustrating part? Many golfers don't even realize they're doing it. They feel like they're making good swings, but their ball flight tells a different story. That's where recognizing these warning signs becomes crucial for improving your golf swing fundamentals.

🎥 Visual Demonstration

Golf instruction video showing over the top swing correction
▶

This video demonstrates how to identify and fix the over-the-top motion

📺 Watch on YouTube →

The 15 Telltale Signs You're Coming Over the Top

Ball Flight Patterns

1. Persistent Slice The most obvious sign is a consistent slice where your ball starts left of target and curves dramatically right. This happens because your over-the-top swing path combined with an open clubface creates sidespin that sends your ball on that banana-shaped flight.

2. Pull-Slice Combination Even worse than a regular slice is when your shots start left and then slice even further left or right. This indicates a severely over-the-top motion where your swing path is dramatically outside-in, but your clubface position varies from shot to shot.

3. Weak, High Ball Flight Your shots lack that penetrating ball flight and instead balloon up in the air without much distance. The steep angle of attack from coming over the top creates excessive backspin and robs you of the compression needed for longer drives.

4. Inconsistent Contact One shot you'll hit it thin, the next you'll hit it fat. The outside-in swing path makes it incredibly difficult to find the bottom of your swing arc consistently, leading to unpredictable contact patterns.

Physical Sensations and Setup Issues

5. Tension in Your Shoulders and Arms If you feel like you're working too hard to hit the ball or your shoulders and arms are tense during your swing, it's often because you're fighting your natural swing plane. Over-the-top swings require more effort and create unnecessary tension throughout your body.

6. Loss of Balance on Your Follow-Through Coming over the top often leaves you falling backward or to your right side (for right-handed golfers) after impact. This happens because the improper swing plane disrupts your natural weight transfer and body rotation.

7. Difficulty Making Solid Contact with Longer Irons The longer the club, the more pronounced the over-the-top motion becomes. If you struggle significantly more with your 5-iron compared to your 9-iron, it's likely because the longer shaft amplifies your swing plane issues.

⚠️ Warning Signs During Your Swing

  • 🔍 Your divots point left of your target line
  • 💪 Excessive tension in shoulders and forearms
  • ⚖️ Falling backward or right after impact

Swing Mechanics Red Flags

8. Your Divots Point Left of Target After hitting an iron shot, check where your divot points. If it's pointing significantly left of your intended target, you're swinging across the ball from outside-in. Proper ball-striking should create divots that point roughly toward your target.

9. Steep Angle of Attack You take deep divots and feel like you're chopping down on the ball rather than sweeping through it. This steep approach is a direct result of the over-the-top motion bringing the club down at too vertical an angle.

10. Early Release or "Casting" Your wrists unhinge too early in the downswing, causing you to lose lag and power. This often happens as a compensation for the over-the-top motion as your body tries to square the clubface at impact.

11. No "Swoosh" Sound on Your Practice Swings When you make practice swings, you should hear the club whoosh through the impact area. If the sound comes early in your swing or sounds weak, it indicates poor swing sequencing often associated with over-the-top mechanics.

Equipment and Training Aid Indicators

12. Struggles with Draw-Biased Clubs If you've tried draw-biased drivers or golf swing trainers designed to promote an inside-out swing and still can't hit draws, it's likely because your swing path is too dramatically over-the-top for the equipment to overcome.

13. Difficulty with Lag Training Aids Training aids designed to create lag and proper sequencing feel awkward or don't work for you. This happens because the over-the-top motion disrupts the natural sequence these aids are designed to promote.

Advanced Detection Methods

14. Video Analysis Shows Outside-In Path If you've recorded your swing from down the line, you can draw a line from your hands at address up through your shoulder. In the downswing, if your hands and club come outside this line, you're coming over the top. Modern swing analysis apps can highlight this swing path clearly.

15. Launch Monitor Numbers Don't Lie If you have access to a launch monitor, look for these telltale signs: negative attack angle with driver, out-to-in club path numbers, and high spin rates with low smash factors. These numbers definitively confirm an over-the-top swing pattern.

Why Do Golfers Come Over the Top?

Understanding why this happens is crucial for fixing it permanently. Most weekend golfers develop this pattern because it feels powerful and natural. When you want to hit the ball hard, your instinct is to throw everything you have at it from the top of your swing.

The problem starts with poor swing tempo and sequencing. Instead of starting the downswing with your lower body and allowing your arms to drop into the proper slot, you fire your shoulders and arms first. This immediately throws the club outside the proper plane.

Physical limitations also play a role. Many golfers lack the hip mobility and core strength needed for proper rotation, so they compensate by using their upper body excessively. Poor setup positions, like standing too far from the ball or having inadequate posture, can also force you into over-the-top patterns.

🎯 Common Causes

  • ⭐ Starting downswing with shoulders instead of hips
  • ⭐ Insufficient hip mobility and core strength
  • ⭐ Poor setup positions and ball position

The Fix: A Step-by-Step Approach

Setup Fundamentals

The fix starts before you even take the club back. Proper setup is crucial for preventing over-the-top motions. Stand tall with your spine tilted slightly away from the target, ensuring you have enough room to swing the club around your body rather than up and down.

Check your grip strength—a grip that's too weak often forces players to come over the top to square the clubface. Work on a neutral grip where you can see 2-3 knuckles on your lead hand when looking down at address.

The Feel of Proper Sequencing

The key to fixing over-the-top is learning proper downswing sequence. Start your downswing by shifting your weight to your lead foot and clearing your hips. Your arms should feel like they're dropping straight down for the first part of the downswing before rotating through impact.

A great practice drill is to place a swing path trainer or headcover about 2 feet behind the ball and slightly outside your target line. Practice swinging without hitting the headcover, which forces you to approach from the inside.

Mental Game Adjustments

Sometimes the fix is mental. Instead of trying to hit the ball hard, focus on swinging through the ball smoothly. Think about skipping a stone across water—the motion is smooth and comes from the inside, not a violent chopping motion.

Many golfers find success by focusing on their finish position. If you can hold your follow-through in perfect balance with your weight on your front foot, you've likely made a good swing that avoided the over-the-top motion.

Training Aids That Actually Work

Certain golf swing training aids can accelerate your progress. The Orange Whip trainer is excellent for developing proper tempo and sequencing. Impact bags help you feel the correct position at impact without worrying about ball flight.

At-home golf training aids like alignment sticks can create swing plane guides that give you immediate feedback about your swing path. Set them up to create a "gate" that forces you to swing from the inside.

Drills to Groove the Correct Motion

The Step-Through Drill

This drill helps you feel the proper weight shift and sequencing. Set up to the ball normally, but as you start your downswing, actually step through with your trail foot. This exaggerated weight shift forces your lower body to lead the downswing and prevents your upper body from taking over.

Practice this drill with slow, smooth swings, focusing on the feeling of your lower body initiating the downswing. Once you get comfortable with the motion, try it with normal swings while keeping that same feeling of lower body leading.

The Pump Drill

Take your normal backswing, but instead of swinging through, pump the club halfway down and back up to the top three times before completing your swing. This helps you feel the correct slot position and prevents the immediate over-the-top move that many golfers make.

During each pump, focus on dropping your hands straight down rather than throwing them out toward the ball. This drill builds muscle memory for the correct downswing plane.

The Baseball Swing Drill

Get into a baseball batting stance and make level swings as if you're hitting a baseball at chest height. This motion naturally teaches you to swing from the inside and can help break the over-the-top pattern.

After making several baseball swings, gradually lower your hands until you're in your normal golf stance. Try to maintain that same inside-out feeling you had when swinging level.

Equipment Solutions and Aids

Driver Adjustments

If you have an adjustable driver, try setting it to a more upright lie angle and closed face angle. This can help compensate for an over-the-top swing path while you work on fixing the underlying mechanics.

Draw-biased drivers with weight positioned to promote right-to-left ball flight can also help, but remember that equipment is just a band-aid if you don't fix the fundamental swing issue.

Training Aid Recommendations

The five swing path training aids that actually work include the Divot Board, which gives immediate feedback about your swing direction, and the PlaneSWING trainer, which physically guides your club on the correct plane.

Tempo trainers like the Tour Tempo app can help you develop the proper rhythm that prevents rushing the downswing with your upper body. Poor tempo is often the root cause of over-the-top swings.

🔧 Quick Fixes That Work

  • ✅ Start downswing with weight shift to front foot
  • ✅ Feel like your hands drop straight down initially
  • ✅ Focus on smooth tempo rather than power

Common Mistakes When Trying to Fix It

Overcompensating with Too Much Inside-Out

Many golfers, once they understand they're coming over the top, try to swing so far from the inside that they start hitting big hooks or blocks. The goal isn't to swing dramatically from the inside—it's to find a neutral swing path that approaches the ball square to slightly from the inside.

Focusing Only on the Downswing

While the over-the-top motion happens in the downswing, the setup often occurs in the backswing or even at address. If your takeaway is too outside or your backswing gets the club in a poor position, you'll be forced to come over the top to make contact with the ball.

Work on your entire swing sequence, not just the downswing. Proper golf swing tips emphasize that every part of the swing affects every other part.

Expecting Immediate Results

Changing a swing pattern you've grooved over years takes time and patience. You might hit some ugly shots while making the change, but that's normal. Trust the process and focus on making the correct motion rather than immediate ball flight results.

Many golfers give up too quickly when their first few attempts produce poor shots. Remember that you're literally rewiring your muscle memory, which takes consistent practice and patience.

The Mental Side of the Fix

Changing Your Swing Thoughts

Instead of thinking "don't come over the top," give yourself positive swing thoughts. Think about "dropping your hands into the slot" or "starting down with your hips." Negative swing thoughts often create tension and make the problem worse.

Visualization can be powerful. Imagine your downswing as a baseball pitcher throwing a ball—the motion starts from the ground up and comes from the inside. This mental image can help your body find the correct pattern.

Building Confidence

As you work on fixing your over-the-top motion, start with shorter clubs where the improvement will be more noticeable. Success with your 8-iron will build confidence that you can apply to longer clubs and your driver.

Practice at the range with specific targets and focus on improved contact and ball flight direction rather than distance. Distance will come naturally once you're swinging on the correct plane.

Advanced Concepts and Professional Help

When to See a Professional

If you've tried these fixes for several weeks without improvement, consider taking a lesson with a qualified instructor. Sometimes an outside eye can spot setup or swing issues that you can't feel or see yourself.

Look for instructors who use video analysis or launch monitor technology. Being able to see your swing and get objective data about your swing path can accelerate the learning process significantly.

Understanding Your Individual Swing

Remember that not every golfer needs to swing exactly the same way. Some successful golfers throughout history have had slightly over-the-top swings but learned to manage them effectively. The goal is to find a swing that produces consistent, acceptable ball flight for your game.

Work with what your body can do naturally while gradually improving the aspects that are hurting your ball striking. Common swing plane mistakes can be corrected, but the process should respect your individual physical capabilities and limitations.

Long-Term Success Strategies

Maintenance and Practice

Once you've made improvements, maintaining them requires ongoing practice and awareness. Dedicate part of each practice session to swing path work, even when you're playing well. It's easier to maintain good habits than to rebuild them after they've deteriorated.

Keep a practice journal noting what swing thoughts and drills work best for you. Every golfer responds differently to various fixes, and having a record of what works for your individual swing can save time and frustration.

Physical Conditioning

Consider incorporating golf-specific fitness work into your routine. Improved hip mobility, core strength, and shoulder flexibility can make it much easier to maintain proper swing mechanics and prevent reverting to over-the-top patterns.

Golf swing training should include both technical work and physical conditioning for optimal results. A body that moves well makes it much easier to swing the club on the correct plane consistently.

Key Takeaways for Weekend Golfers

If you recognize several of these signs in your own game, don't panic. Coming over the top is one of the most common swing faults, and it's definitely fixable with patience and proper practice. The key is understanding that this isn't just a swing plane issue—it's usually a sequencing problem that starts with how you begin your downswing.

Focus on starting your downswing with your lower body while allowing your arms to drop into the correct position. Practice with purpose, using drills and training aids that give you immediate feedback about your swing path. Most importantly, be patient with yourself as you make these changes.

Remember that even small improvements in swing path can lead to dramatically better ball flight. You don't need a perfect swing—you just need one that's good enough to enjoy your weekend rounds and maybe steal a few dollars from your buddies.

The satisfaction of finally hitting that long, straight drive down the middle of the fairway will make all the practice worth it. And once you've tamed your over-the-top tendency, you'll wonder why you waited so long to fix it.

Your Over-the-Top Swing Questions Answered

What is the most obvious sign that I'm coming over the top? The most obvious sign is a persistent slice where your ball starts left of target and curves dramatically right. This happens because your out-to-in swing path combined with an open clubface creates sidespin that sends your ball on a banana-shaped flight pattern.

Can I fix an over-the-top swing without taking lessons? Yes, many golfers can fix over-the-top swings through focused practice using the right drills and training aids. Key fixes include starting your downswing with your lower body, using swing path trainers, and practicing proper sequencing drills. However, video analysis or professional instruction can accelerate the process.

How long does it take to fix an over-the-top swing? The time varies depending on how ingrained the pattern is and how often you practice. Most golfers see noticeable improvement within 3-6 weeks of focused practice, but fully grooming the new pattern can take 2-3 months of consistent work. Be patient and focus on proper motion rather than immediate results.

What's the difference between coming over the top and an outside-in swing path? Coming over the top refers to the club moving above the proper swing plane during the downswing, which typically results in an outside-in swing path. However, not all outside-in paths are caused by over-the-top motions. Some golfers can have a slightly outside-in path while still staying on plane.

Should I use equipment to help fix my over-the-top swing? Equipment like draw-biased drivers or swing trainers can help compensate temporarily, but they won't fix the underlying swing issue. Use training aids like headcover drills, swing path trainers, or tempo trainers to practice proper mechanics, but focus on fixing the swing fundamentals for long-term improvement.

Show / Hide

Essential Swing Path Resources for Better Ball Striking